Skip to content
Home
Employment LawSuccess StoriesNews

Global Talent and Innovator Founder Review: What the MAC Recommends for Each Route

The MAC says Global Talent is “largely meeting its objectives” and Innovator Founder is not, and recommends abolishing Innovator Founder in its current form.

8 minute read

Global Talent and Innovator Founder Review: What the MAC Recommends for Each Route
Add Nara Solicitors as a preferred source on Google

The Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) has published its Review of Talent Routes, covering the Global Talent and Innovator Founder routes. The MAC states that “the Global Talent route is largely meeting its objectives, and that the Innovator Founder route is not.”

About the review

The MAC wrote to the Home Secretary on 27 February 2026 about its intention to launch a self-commissioned review. The review used:

•       Home Office administrative data, HMRC earnings and employment records, and Migrant Journey data

•       A Call for Evidence (5 March to 1 May 2026) that received over 400 responses

•       Discussions with all Endorsing Bodies and sub-Endorsing Bodies

•       Stakeholder roundtables and previous Home Office evaluations of Global Talent

Visa numbers

Around 58,600 visas were issued across the two routes between FY2022/23 and FY2025/26:

•       Global Talent: 55,200 visas (32,800 main applicants and 22,400 dependants).

•       Innovator Founder: 3,400 visas (1,600 main applicants and 1,800 dependants) in the first three years since its introduction in April 2023. Volumes were highest in FY2023/24 (1,700) and fell to 800 by FY2025/26.

The MAC notes that only 1.6% of all work-related visas in 2025 were talent-related, although there will be talented migrants across other work routes.

Global Talent

Findings

•       Global Talent visa holders have no salary or employment requirements. The MAC says their employment rate is high and their earnings “respectable, if not stellar”.

•       Holders earn less than Skilled Worker visa holders, which the MAC says is primarily because such a high share are in academia. Holding industry constant, average earnings are comparable to the Skilled Worker route.

•       The median income for main applicants in the second year is £42,800. The MAC says this conceals significant differences between sectors.

•       The MAC’s fiscal model estimates that the cohort arriving in 2022/23 is expected to have a positive net fiscal impact over their lifetimes of approximately £420,000 per person, or £2.2bn overall. This is 43% less per person than the Skilled Worker route, reflecting the higher representation in lower-paying industries.

•       Between 8% and 21% of main applicants granted visas in 2022/23 had earnings below £12,571 in their second year, the proposed Earned Settlement minimum income threshold.

•       Between 14% and 28% of main applicants granted visas in 2022/23 had taxable earnings below £22,300 in their second year. The MAC says this is approximately the annual earnings of someone working full time at the 2024/25 National Living Wage.

•       The lower end of each range counts only people with reported earnings below the threshold. The upper end also includes people with no recorded earnings. The range reflects uncertainty about whether those people were in the UK or had earnings not captured in the data.

•       The bottom 20% on the route have a negative lifetime fiscal impact. The MAC describes this as “concerning for a route aimed at globally talented individuals”.

Recommendations

•       Reference letters for endorsement should be submitted directly and confidentially to Endorsing Bodies, given the “risks of alteration, fabrication and influence of personal relationships”.

•       The Home Office should introduce guidelines to prevent referees supporting applicants where there is a conflict of interest.

•       Do not significantly dilute eligibility requirements. The MAC takes no position on the precise scope of eligible occupations.

•       The Home Office should consider the feasibility of expanding the fast-track process for specific positions within highly reputable arts and tech organisations with an excellent record of compliance in the Skilled Worker route.

•       The Home Office should work with Endorsing Bodies on how the number of peer review applications could be reduced by raising the bar for a full review, while maintaining the integrity of the overall bar for endorsement.

•       No full-scale assessment of contribution at settlement. Instead, the Home Office should consider options for a light-touch assessment giving more confidence that the applicant had been working in the field of endorsement, without onerous documentary requirements.

•       A salary requirement at settlement set at a level needed to sustain a basic standard of living, with at least a full-time National Living Wage threshold.

•       The Home Office should record which Endorsing Body endorsed each visa application, in a consistent format, to allow fuller statistical analysis.

Innovator Founder

Findings

•       The MAC says the route “has not cracked the problem” and that the available evidence suggests it “is not working as intended”.

•       The MAC states that the median Innovator Founder business has roughly the turnover of a small independent coffee shop by the time visa holders apply for settlement (after 3 years).

•       At firm age four, median turnover was approximately £105,000, compared with £360,000 for UK-owned comparators. The MAC notes that an average UK independent coffee shop generates between £100,000 and £150,000 in annual turnover.

•       In their fourth year, around 53% of Innovator Founder businesses reported turnover of £100,000 or less, compared with 30% of comparator firms. Over 5% generated over £1 million, compared with 25% of comparators.

•       The MAC notes the comparison group is drawn from businesses registered for PAYE and/or VAT, so it is less likely to include very small businesses. It says this may partly explain the comparison group’s higher share above £1 million.

•       Median employment was between one and two employees across the first five years, some of whom are likely to be the visa holders themselves. The MAC says this suggests the route is not leading to significant job creation.

•       Median personal income in the second year was £15,800 (mean £31,100).

•       Estimated Corporation Tax under the median profit assumption is around £1,300 to £2,800 per business per year. The MAC did not have profit or Corporation Tax data and estimated this from turnover.

•       The highest-performing firm generated over £200m in its fourth year. The MAC states that “a small percentage” of visa holders and businesses appear to perform very well.

•       The MAC states that this does not make up for the poor outcomes for the majority and “may not be sufficient to prevent the route from creating a net fiscal cost over the long term”. It also says there is a significant chance the route is fiscally costly in both the long and short term.

Recommendations

•       The government should abolish the Innovator Founder route in its current form.

•       If the government keeps the route open, the Home Office should:

–      Immediately undertake substantial reform of the eligibility, endorsement and settlement process to make the route much more selective.

–      Urgently improve data quality (personal income, business profits, innovation measures and corporate tax paid, and how these vary by Endorsing Body), then review the route again in one year with a view to closing it unless new data show a considerable improvement.

–      Retain interviews as part of the assessment.

–      Not remove innovation as a core eligibility criterion unless it is replaced with a similarly stringent criterion.

–      Review whether the scalability criterion is strong enough.

–      Strengthen information sharing on disputed endorsed cases.

–      Allow Endorsing Bodies to offer paid additional services only to visa holders endorsed by other Innovator Founder Endorsing Bodies, to avoid a conflict of interest.

–      Extend the time to settlement to five years and consider making the business success requirements more robust.

–      Set a personal income requirement at settlement of at least the full-time National Living Wage, implemented with appropriate flexibility for temporary personal circumstances in cases of illness or parental leave.

•       The MAC does not recommend liberalising the route at this time. This includes the stakeholder suggestions to relax the innovation requirement or to prevent UKVI from questioning Endorsing Bodies’ endorsements.

Investors

The MAC states that investors are not currently eligible for any talent route, as the previous investor route closed in 2022. The review did not examine the impacts of financial investment, as it focused on individual talent.

It looked at whether talented investors could be admitted through Innovator Founder, Global Talent or a standalone route, and recommends against all three. The MAC states it does not believe current models could distinguish talented investors from the large number of other wealthy people who would use an investor route with limited economic benefits.

Cross-cutting recommendations

•       Review uptake of Global Talent in deep tech, AI and quantum once the announced fee reimbursement is implemented, and assess whether the costs versus economic benefits make it sensible to extend this further.

•       Conduct a major review of all Global Talent and Innovator Founder guidance (Endorsing Body and Home Office guidance) and review it annually.

 

This article summarises the MAC’s Review of Talent Routes (November 2026). It is not legal advice.

Get in touch with Nara Solicitors

Get in touch with Nara Solicitors

Book a consultation with Nara Solicitors to get legal advise for your query.

Book a Consultation with us
Add Nara Solicitors as a preferred source

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter

We send weekly expert guides and useful resources to our subscribers.

By subscribing you agree to receive emails from Nara Solicitors. See our privacy policy.